The Old Mill Inn — Good food, local wines & a touch of old Long Island - Your waterfront getaway for dining since 1821


Thursday - Sunday

Lunch & Dinner

Join us for Happy Hour... 3:30 - 7pm!


Photo Gallery
Deck at the Old Mill.jpg
Sunset Photo
Drinks at the Old Mill Inn
Photo Gallery
Photo Gallery
Photo Gallery
Photo Gallery

5775 West Mill Rd.  bullet  Mattituck, NY 11952

(631) 298-8080  bullet   oldmillinn@aol.com

Enjoy the bounty of the North Fork’s waters and farms at the historic Old Mill Inn. Relax with a cocktail or a glass of local wine, and savor an unspoiled corner of Long Island.

Whether in our dining room or outside on our deck overlooking Mattituck inlet, The Old Mill is a great spot for viewing birds, fishing boats and a sunset or two. For generations friends have been coming down to the pub for lively, fireside conversation. So make that turn off Route 48, drive north towards The Sound, and become a part of our living history.



Follow us on Twitter and Facebook

Find us on facebookFollow us on twitter
Visit our blog

Dan's Papers
Best of the Best 2013
WINNER OF OVER 10 AWARDS INCLUDING:

  • Best Seafood
  • Best Bar
  • Best Waterview
  • Best Restaurant Atmosphere

THANK YOU FOR YOUR VOTES!!

Fresh Oysters

$1 each, 3:30 - 7pm in the pub during Happy Hour.

JOIN US

NOVEMBER 1st, 8pm
HALLOWEEN FUN!

Gene Casey & The Lone Sharks

Rockabilly, Dancing, Costumes, Mischief...

It's our closing celebration and we like to pull out the stops!

Email Newsletter

Enter your email address to receive our newsletter.

Safe and Secure online processing icon