5775 West Mill Rd. 
Mattituck, NY 11952
(631) 298-8080
oldmillinn@aol.com
Enjoy the bounty of the North Fork’s waters and farms at the historic Old Mill Inn. Relax with a cocktail or a glass of local wine, and savor an unspoiled corner of Long Island.
Whether in our dining room or outside on our deck overlooking Mattituck inlet, The Old Mill is a great spot for viewing birds, fishing boats and a sunset or two. For generations friends have been coming down to the pub for lively, fireside conversation. So make that turn off Route 48, drive north towards The Sound, and become a part of our living history.
Thanks for voting!
We won Best Bar on the North Fork and Best Desserts in Best of the Best, Dan's Papers.
Fresh Oysters
Oysters $1 each 3-5pm in the bar.
You Catch...We Cook
Bring in your catch by 2 p.m. We'll pan-sear, oven-roast or grill for $23 a plate.
